Planning a BDSM Scene? If You’re Not Asking This Question, You’re Doing It Wrong

(Spoiler: It’s not “What do you want to do?”)

Hello, I’m Mistress Seren. I am a professional Dominatrix and BDSM Couples Coach. Welcome to my dark corner of Substack, where I pull back the veil on the world of kink. Here, you’ll find raw, unfiltered stories from the dungeon, expert insights on how to Dominate like a pro, and my thoughts on power, pain, and pleasure. You still want more? I know. You can visit my website or follow me on X and Instagram.

---

Before I see a client in person, I have a 30-minute video call with them. This serves many purposes: rapport building, safety check, and my way of truly understanding the submissive who might get invited to walk through my dungeon door.

I always ask, “What is a moment you wish you could relive?” Typically, they answer my question by describing the actions of their former Domina.

“First, she put an O-ring ball gag in my mouth. Then she was sucking on a Jolly Rancher and spit in my mouth over and over again.”

This may reveal this particular sub enjoys receiving spit, and I can assume they like not being in control of their body—but these are merely assumptions. So, I ask the question that will define my scene with them:

“How do you want to feel with me?”

“I want to feel catharsis.” He responded. He had gone through a hard breakup and was feeling guilty for sleeping with his ex afterward. He wanted punishment—not just as an act, but as an emotional purge—a vastly different scene than being forced to swallow candy-flavored spit.

It’s easy to get caught up planning BDSM scenes around activities—spanking, bondage, worship. What makes a scene unforgettable isn’t the act itself. It’s the feeling you create inside your sub.

Exploring the Emotional Landscape of BDSM

I’ve consulted hundreds of submissive men on their desires for a scene with me. Some have a hard time answering the question, and others give the common themes one might expect:

• Controlled – Helpless, bound, at my mercy.

• Owned – Marked, claimed, belonging to me.

• Disciplined – Corrected, shaped into something better.

• Humiliated – Embarrassed, degraded, made small.

• Masochistic – Pain as pleasure, suffering as surrender.

• Punished – Atoning for their bad behavior.

But the list of what’s possible is far longer.

What will take your scene play to the next level is considering the vast range of feelings you can evoke in your sub.

It also requires you, as the Dominant and the submissive, to know what you want.

This is where the interpersonal work begins, and it is the work required to have the most satisfying scenes. It is the conscious awareness of your desires.

Let’s Begin - The Full Spectrum of Feelings in BDSM

Take a deep breath. Below is a long list. Don’t speed read—let each word and its meaning sink in. Then, ask yourself: Would I want to experience that feeling?

Adored, Cherished, Belonging, Desirable, Nurtured, Protected, Serene, Valuable, Worthy, Accepted, Appreciated, Admired, Confident, Precious, Joyous, Meditative, Grateful, Loved, Relaxed, Respected, Spiritual, Special, Obedient, Helpless.

Abused, Ruined, Broken Down, Worthless, Cathartic, Consumed, Filthy, Scared, Degraded, Overwhelmed, Rejected, Stupid, Disrespected, Shamed, Humiliated, Guilty, Objectified, Brainless, Inferior, Tiny, Prey, Threatened, Sacrificial, Unworthy, Weak.

Victorious, Free, Challenged, Unbreakable, Irreplaceable, Tough, Transcendent, Villainous, Wild, Clever, Competitive, Surprised, Ecstatic, Excited, Amused, Creative, Genderless, Feminine, Masculine, Innocent, Childish, Intense, Irresistible, Needed, Parented, Performative, Slutty, Protected, Shameless, Seen.

Good job, my sub(scriber).

Upon reading that, I am sure you started to notice some distinctions. There were feelings that you would need in a scene to be successful; I call those the Essential Feelings. Then there are the Edgy Feelings, which you may want to explore but infrequently and might require a specific headspace.

Homework:

Encourage your submissive to choose five feelings they want to explore in a scene based on the list above. Then go deeper:

• What feelings are essential for you to surrender?

• Which feelings intrigue you but require a specific mindset or extra negotiation?

• Why do you desire to experience this feeling?

• What would accessing this feeling unlock within you?

The Dominant’s Role: Embodying the Emotion

Consent runs both ways. When your submissive desires to explore a specific feeling, you must want to evoke that within them. Do not attempt to create a feeling that you are not comfortable with.

Here’s why:

“7% of communication is conveyed through spoken words (verbal), while 38% is communicated through tone of voice and 55% through body language, meaning we pick up significantly more information from body language than verbal cues.”

You might say the right words or perform the right actions, but if your body language and energy do not align with the feeling you’re trying to create, your submissive will sense the disconnect. This is confusing for your submissive, and your scene will flop. And worse…

This creates distrust within yourself and between you and your play partner.

To guide a submissive into an emotional state, you must authentically embody it.

• If they want to feel nurtured, be nurturing.

• If they want to be degraded, be degrading.

Before a scene, ask yourself:

• Do I genuinely desire to create this feeling for them?

• Can I embody the characteristics required to provoke this emotion?

From Action to Emotion: How to Build a Scene

Let’s take a commonly requested action—flogging—and show how it can be two entirely different emotional experiences.

If my sub requested to feel:

1. Confident + Challenged

At the beginning:

Frame it as a trial of endurance. Use affirming language:

“Today is going to be a big day for you. You will reach new heights in what you can take. I know you can take it—for me, and for yourself.”

“I am going to push your limits today, but I know you want that, don’t you?”

“Say, ‘I know I can. I know I can do it.’”

During the Scene:

• Use a mirror: Let them see how much they can receive.

• Take breaks to admire their marks.

• Reinforce their strength:

  • “Look how strong you are for me.”

  • “With every stroke, say ‘I can take it.’”

2. Exposed + Sacrificial

At the beginning:
Strip them slowly, emphasizing their vulnerability. Circle them, describing their body. Whisper: “You are mine to play with. I will use your body and your pain for my pleasure.”

During the Scene:

• Use bondage and body position to expose them while flogging:

  • Bound them to a St. Andrew’s Cross, facing you.

  • Put them over a Spanking bench.

  • Tie them up to four corners of a bed.

• Reinforce their submission:

  • “Look at you—completely open, completely mine.”

  • “You exist for my pleasure, and I am going to use your body for it.”

Final Considerations for Scene Design

Every detail contributes to the emotional tone of a scene:

• Your sub’s level of dress

• Your sub’s body position

• Intensity of Play

• The Dom/me’s Language & Tone

• Music & Environment

The art of a well-crafted scene isn’t just about what happens—it’s about how it makes your submissive feel.